Written by Daisy O’Rawe, Co-President of Lancaster University Maths Association
Lecture recordings are a heavily debated topic in higher education. Legal, pedagogical, and personal reasons are all given to support and oppose the need for recordings. As a student with a disability, I feel it is often overlooked just how essential these recordings are to people like me.
Whilst I personally believe recordings are a useful tool for everyone, regardless of disability, I can say from personal experience that without lecture recordings I would not be able to attend university. It is frequently misunderstood that adjustments, like lecture recordings, are there to make university easier for people with disabilities. Many of these adjustments simply make a university education feasible. Despite overall achieving a First, I have failed a module – the only module I have ever had without lecture recordings provided. It is therefore straightforward for me to see that if recordings weren’t so widely available, not only would I not be achieving the grades I am more than capable of – I would not be in university at all.
After hearing from other students with disabilities about how a lack of lecture recordings also strongly affected them, I became determined to improve the recording system. In my role as academic rep, I had some informative meetings with members of LUSU and the maths department, in which a main theme emerged: although the University has policies that individual departments cannot change, each department can implement positive changes that would greatly benefit those who require recordings.
With that in mind, I worked with the maths department on creating a new policy that could improve the lecture recording process at a departmental level. I noticed that a lot of the issues that could be fixed at a departmental level were split into three sections: informing, communicating and monitoring.
Informing
Whilst each lecturer may have their own pedagogical reasons for not providing recordings, a common one that comes up is attendance. It is easy to see why this would be a concern, though it is not substantiated. In fact, Lancaster's own regulations state, “You should avoid withholding recordings to improve attendance figures as this isn’t likely to work and disadvantages all students.” (Lancaster University, n.d., section 3.3). Further, the primary people these recordings are supposed to benefit are not missing lectures because they want to; they’re missing lectures because their disability causes them to. In fact, the majority of people with disabilities would prefer to attend physically (Horlin et al., 2024, p. 2086). Withholding recordings from students with disabilities because of concerns over attendance of students without disabilities is hardly fair.
The first part of our new policy focuses on informing lecturers about the different access modes available. Lecturers should know that compromises can be made regarding recordings, and that adjustments can be made for people who require them without disregarding their teaching philosophies.
One important thing that the policy outlines is recordings with restricted access, making recordings available to those who need them, rather than releasing them to the entire cohort. The Student Office can identify students who require access, for example, those with Individual Learning Support Plans (ILSPs), and create a restricted section on the module's Moodle page that lecturers can upload recordings to. The rationale behind this approach was to help ease lecturers' concerns about attendance without denying an important adjustment to disabled students. The new policy also states that recordings should be made available within two days; this is especially important as it ensures students are not falling behind while waiting for recordings to be uploaded.
It is also important that lecturers are aware of the different levels of recording access to support those who are not registered as having specific permission to access recordings.
Under the new policy, the chosen approach should be communicated to students in advance and clearly stated on the module's Moodle page.
The four options are:
1. Immediate availability: Recordings are made available to all students shortly after each lecture.
2. Delayed availability: Recordings are withheld during the teaching period and released afterwards, allowing students to use them for revision.
3. Temporary availability: Recordings are made available shortly after the lecture but removed after a specified period, for example, one week.
4. No availability: Recordings are not made available to the general student body.
Students who require lecture recordings as a reasonable adjustment must retain access regardless of which option is selected for the wider cohort.
Communicating
Proper communication is just as important as the adjustments themselves. A key theme throughout the policy is that staff and the University, not the students themselves, should be responsible for proactively providing reasonable adjustments, rather than requiring students to repeatedly request adjustments.
The policy states that when a module does not provide lecture recordings, students must be informed at the beginning of the module. It also requires lecturers to proactively contact those with ILSPs to offer suitable alternative arrangements. Furthermore, where full recording availability is not provided to all students, the department should provide a brief explanation of the rationale behind this decision.
This helps students understand why a particular approach has been adopted and encourages transparency in departmental decision-making.
Monitoring
The final component of the policy introduces a monitoring process to ensure that the requirements are actually being implemented, and nothing is slipping through the cracks.
During the second week of each module, a designated staff member, such as the Director of Teaching, should check the module's Moodle page to ensure that the policy is being followed. This would include: confirming that recordings are being provided to students who require them, or that appropriate alternative arrangements are being supplied; checking that adequate communication is given; and identifying whether any frequent technical issues are happening, and ensuring steps are taken to fix them.
Without a monitoring process, issues can go unnoticed, particularly when the affected students may represent a small proportion of the cohort, may feel uncomfortable raising concerns or may already be dealing with significant challenges in their academic life.
Relying solely on students to report failures is not always effective, and a small check can be easily implemented, yet could make a substantial difference to students who depend on recordings.
The monitoring process also helps ensure consistency across modules, rather than leaving the quality of reasonable adjustments dependent on individual lecturers and can help out any lecturers who are having significant technical difficulties without them having to sort everything themselves.
This policy is designed to improve the already established lecture recording process and encourage those who don’t already record their lectures that accommodation can be made without disregarding their own opinions.
This new policy has been a very positive change in the maths department, and one that I can personally say has impacted me in a good way. I hope that other departments can also implement similar changes regarding lecture recordings and that the university continues to improve recording policies, and other reasonable adjustments, for those with disabilities. These adjustments can open up education to whole new groups of people who never would have been able to access it before. Most importantly, departments need to continue to listen, and act, on concerns and ideas brought to them by people with disabilities.
References
Horlin, C., Hronska, B. and Nordmann, E. (2024) ‘I can be a “normal” student: the role of lecture capture in supporting disabled and neurodivergent students’ participation in higher education’, Higher Education, 88(6), pp. 2075–2092. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-024-01201-5.
Lancaster University (n.d.) VLE baseline. Available at: https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/embed-digital/digital-teaching-and-learning/vle-baseline/ (Accessed: 8 November 2026).